Rights and Obligations of the Musatah (Surface Right Holder)

Rights of the Musatah

The Iraqi legislator has paid careful attention to regulating the rights of the Musatah (the holder of the right of Musataha/Surface Right).

This regulation is clearly defined in both the Civil Code and the Real Estate Registration Law.

These rights are detailed as follows:

1. Ownership of Constructions and Right of Disposal

According to Article 1269/Para 1 of the Civil Code, the Musatah possesses pure ownership of any buildings or other facilities they have erected on the land.

The Musatah has the right to dispose of these structures, coupled with the Musataha right itself, through:

Sale.
Mortgage.
Other contracts of ownership transfer.

These transactions must be registered at the Real Estate Registration Department.

This right is exercised without prejudice to the land owner's rights or the purpose for which the buildings or facilities were intended, unless an agreement exists to the contrary.

Furthermore, Article 232/Para 1 of the Real Estate Registration Law confirms this by stating that:

The Musatah owns the buildings and facilities they have established as pure property.
All legal dispositions can be applied to these structures, coupled with the Musataha right.
There is no need for the land owner's approval for these dispositions.
The Musatah may even dispose of the Musataha right itself before commencing construction, unless there is an agreement prohibiting this.

The Nature of this Ownership: Consequently, the Musatah holds ownership of the buildings and facilities constructed on the owner's land.

This is described as a right of pure ownership established for the Musatah immediately upon construction.
However, this ownership is characterized as temporary, as it typically ceases upon the expiration of the specific term of the Musataha contract.

Legal Implications of this Right: Based on this established right, the Musatah has the authority to dispose of their buildings and facilities through all types of legal transactions, coupled with the Musataha right. They may:

Sell them.
Gift them.
Mortgage them.
Bequeath them after death (whether to the land owner or a third party).
Transfer them to third parties with or without consideration.

Liability Note: It is important to note that the Musatah's disposal of their right to another person does not exempt them from their responsibilities regarding obligations to the land owner arising from the contract. They remain liable for these obligations unless the parties agree otherwise.

Restrictions on Ownership: The ownership held by the Musatah is not absolute; rather, it is subject to fundamental restrictions:

Scope Limitation: It is confined strictly to the buildings and facilities constructed by the Musatah personally on the land. It does not extend to the land itself, which remains the property of its original owner.
Purpose Restriction: It is restricted by the purpose for which the building or facilities were prepared. The Musatah may not alter this purpose in a manner that conflicts with the land owner's rights or the terms agreed upon in the contract.
Temporal Limitation: It is a temporary ownership by nature. It extinguishes upon the expiration of the specified duration of the Musataha right, whether this duration was agreed upon in the contract or prescribed by law.

2. Authority to Use and Enjoy the Land

The Musatah has the authority to utilize the land and use it for erecting buildings and facilities in accordance with the agreement made with the land owner.

A distinguishing feature of this right is flexibility:

The Musatah may dispose of the right even before actually commencing construction.
This applies unless there is an agreement preventing such action.
This grants the Musatah wide flexibility in managing their rights and disposing of them as their interests dictate.

3. Transfer of Rights via Inheritance and Wills

The Right of Musataha, in both its aspects (the right to build and the facilities themselves), is transferable through inheritance and wills.

This is in accordance with Article 1269 of the Iraqi Civil Code.

The transfer via these two methods is governed by the general rules established in Sharia and Law, as they are considered causes for acquiring ownership:

Inheritance: If the Musatah passes away, their right devolves to their legal heirs according to their shares as determined in the Sharia succession decree (Qassam Shar'i).
Wills: The Musatah may also bequeath this right through a will, within the limits of one-third of their estate.

Obligations of the Musatah in the Musataha Contract

As a party to the Musataha contract (Surface Right Contract), the Musatah (Surface Right Holder) bears a set of obligations mandated by both the agreement and the law.

These obligations must be executed in accordance with the content of the contract and in the manner required by the principle of Good Faith in the performance of contracts.

Since the source of the Musataha right is the contract itself, its provisions are the primary reference for determining the scope and extent of these obligations.

These obligations are detailed as follows:

1. Obligation to Construct and Maintain

Construction within the Timeframe

The Musatah is obligated to erect the building or facilities agreed upon with the land owner in the Musataha contract. This must be completed within the specific period stipulated in the contract.

Adherence to the Agreed Purpose

Linked to this obligation is the duty to use the land strictly for the purpose for which it was prepared, as agreed upon.

The Musatah applies to the land only for the agreed objectives.
They may not change the nature of the building.
They may not make a fundamental modification to the purpose for which the land was allocated.

Example: It is not one's right to construct a residential building if the agreement was specifically for the construction of a garage for transporting travelers.

Duty of Care

The Musatah is committed to exerting the "care of a reasonable person" in looking after the land. They must not undertake any physical actions that would:

Cause a change in its nature.
Cause damage to it.

2. Utilization of the Land's Subsurface (Underground)

The Prevailing Legal Opinion

Regarding the extent to which the Musatah may exploit the interior (subsurface) of the land to erect facilities, the prevailing opinion—which aligns with the nature of the Musataha contract—is that there is no impediment to this.

The Musatah may exploit the subsurface of the land provided that it is an integral part of the buildings or facilities they have constructed.

These structures will ultimately revert to the land owner upon the expiration of the Musataha contract term, whether it ends by mutual consent or by judicial order.

Legal Basis: Article 1266

This view is supported by Article 1266 of the Iraqi Civil Code No. 40 of 1951, which states:

(The right of Musataha is a real right that authorizes its holder to erect a building or other facilities, other than planting, on the land of another pursuant to an agreement between him and the land owner. This agreement determines the rights and obligations of the Musatah).

This text is devoid of any explicit prohibition on building underground.

Practical Necessity

Furthermore, the nature of certain buildings and facilities may necessarily require the exploitation of the subsurface to complete them. Examples include:

The construction of residential buildings requiring the creation of shelters/bunkers beneath them.
The construction of swimming pools in tourist hotels.

3. Payment of Remuneration (Rent)

The Musatah is obligated to pay the rent to the land owner at the times specified in the contract. This applies in cases where payment of consideration for the Musataha right is a condition.

Consequences of Default (Article 1268)

According to Article 1268 of the Iraqi Civil Code No. 40 of 1951:

If the Musatah refuses to pay or delays payment for three consecutive years, the land owner has the right to request the rescission (termination) of the contract from the competent court.
This applies unless there is an agreement to the contrary.

Lump-Sum Payment

The parties may agree that the rent be paid in one lump sum covering the entire duration of the Musataha. In this case, the land owner has no right to demand additional rent thereafter.

4. Return of the Land

Upon the expiration of the Musataha right, the Musatah is obligated to return the land to its owner, along with the buildings or facilities constructed upon it.

Removal of Encumbrances

The Musatah must remove any "occupancies" or encumbrances attached to that building or those facilities which the land owner refuses to accept.

Prohibition on Overstaying

The Musatah may not lease the location of the Musataha contract to a third party except within the duration of the contract.
If they continue to dispose of the property after the expiration of the term without the land owner's consent, they are considered a Usurper (Wrongful Possessor).
They must return the premises to the owner pursuant to the provisions of Articles 197 and 198 of the Iraqi Civil Code No. 40 of 1951.

5. Reconstruction and Liability for Destruction

Destruction Due to Fault

The Musatah is under an obligation to rebuild the buildings or facilities they erected if their collapse was caused by the Musatah's own fault.

Destruction Due to Foreign Cause

If the collapse was caused by a foreign cause beyond their control (Force Majeure), such as an earthquake or flood:

The Musatah is not obligated to rebuild.
The land owner does not have the right to demand rebuilding.

Rights After Destruction (Article 1267/Para 2)

In the event of destruction by a foreign cause, the Musatah has the right to hand over the land to another person to utilize until the end of the Musataha term.

This is because the Right of Musataha does not extinguish with the disappearance of the building before the end of the prescribed term, as stated in Article 1267/Para 2 of the Iraqi Civil Code No. 40 of 1951.

This means the right remains valid and productive of its legal effects regardless of whether the building remains or not, as long as the contract period has not yet expired.

Transfer of the Right of Musataha

Scope of Ownership and Disposal Authority

It has been previously established that the Musatah (Surface Right Holder) possesses pure ownership of the buildings and facilities they erect on the land. Consequently, they have the right to dispose of these structures—coupled with the Musataha right—through various types of legal transactions.

Based on the text of Article 1269 of the Iraqi Civil Code No. 40 of 1951: The Musatah is authorized to transfer the ownership of the buildings and facilities they have constructed to third parties.

This transfer may occur through:

Sale.
Mortgage.
Gift (Donation).
Will (Testament).
Lease.

Conditions for Disposal:

The Recipient: The disposal is valid whether the recipient is the land owner themselves or any other person.
Consideration: It is valid whether the transfer is for a price (with consideration) or without consideration.
Registration: The transaction must be concluded at the Real Estate Registration Department.
Non-Prejudice: The act must not prejudice the rights of the land owner or the purpose for which the building or facilities were prepared.

Separation of Land and Building Ownership

It is crucial to note that the Musatah's disposal is strictly confined to the buildings and facilities they personally constructed on the land.

Exclusion of Land: This disposal does not extend to the "neck" (corpus) of the land itself, which remains the property of the original owner.
Independent Ownerships: There are two independent ownerships, separate from one another, as clarified by Articles 1269 and 1270 of the Civil Code.

Therefore, when a Musatah disposes of their right to the buildings they erected on another's land, they are disposing of the Musataha right accordingly. They are legally required to inform the recipient that only the Musataha right is being transferred, not the ownership of the land itself.

Forms of Transfer

The transfer of the Musataha right takes multiple forms:

Assignment: The Musatah may waive their right and transfer it to the land owner or any other person.
Wills: They may transfer this right via a will, provided the bequest does not exceed one-third of the estate, if the estate consists solely of the Musataha right.
Conditional Gift: The Musatah may dispose of the right through a conditional gift.
Mortgage: The right may be mortgaged. In this case, the mortgagee (creditor) has the right to dispose of this right if the Musatah fails to fulfill their obligations toward them.

Characteristics of Mortgaging the Musataha Right

A distinguishing feature of mortgaging the Musataha right is that the mortgage does not extinguish upon the destruction of the buildings and facilities.

Reasoning: The mortgage is not limited to the physical structures but encompasses the Musataha right itself.
Legal Basis: The right does not cease with the disappearance of the building before the end of the term, pursuant to Article 1267/Para 2 of the Iraqi Civil Code No. 40 of 1951.
Compensation: Upon the expiration of the Musataha right, the mortgagee's right shifts to the compensation amount that the Musatah is entitled to receive from the land owner, in accordance with Article 1270 of the Civil Code.

Transfer via Inheritance

Regarding the transfer of the Musataha right through inheritance:

Survival of Right: This right does not extinguish upon the death of the Musatah, as long as the contract term has not yet expired.
Devolution: It transfers to their heirs, each according to their share of the estate.
Legal Basis: This is stipulated in Article 1269/Para 2 of the Civil Code.

Effects of Termination and Destruction

Upon Expiration: When the Musataha right ends due to the expiration of its term or any other cause of termination:

Transfer to Land Owner: The ownership of the buildings and facilities transfers to the land owner.
Compensation: The land owner must pay the Musatah the value of these structures as due for removal (debris value), according to Article 1270 of the Civil Code.
Status of Fixtures: At this point, these improvements become fixtures of the land and are subject to the same rules governing the land itself.

Destruction of Buildings: Finally, it is observed that the Musataha right does not cease merely because the building is destroyed before the end of the prescribed term for the right.

Legal Basis: Article 1267/Para 2 of the Civil Code.
Implication: The right remains valid and productive of its legal effects, independent of the physical existence of the building, as long as the contract duration has not yet elapsed.

Amendment of the Musataha Contract

Fundamentally, the Right of Musataha is based on the contract or agreement concluded between the land owner and the Musatah (Surface Right Holder).

The general principle is that once a contract is executed, it becomes binding on both parties. Consequently:

Neither contracting party may independently revoke or amend it.
Amendment must occur either by virtue of a legal provision or by mutual consent between the parties.

This is in accordance with Article 146 of the Iraqi Civil Code No. 40 of 1951.

Based on this foundation, the amendment of a Musataha contract is achieved through one of two methods:

Consensual Agreement: Mutual agreement between the contracting parties.
Judicial Recourse: Resorting to the judiciary if such agreement is impossible.

In this regard, the general rules contained in the Iraqi Civil Code may be applied to the Musataha contract in cases where the specific provisions for this contract lack a text regulating the issue of amendment, or if there is no agreement between the parties regarding it.

The Theory of Unforeseen Circumstances (Hardship)

The issue of amending the Musataha contract holds special importance because it is considered a Contract of Continuous Execution (Long-term Contract).

Time as a Pillar: The duration constitutes an essential pillar; the contract cannot be conceived without it.
Benefit Realization: The expected benefit is only realized through the passage of time.
Proportional Execution: The contract is considered executed in parts proportional to the period that has elapsed.

This continuous nature makes the Musataha contract a valid subject for the application of the Theory of Unforeseen Circumstances stipulated in Article 146 of the Iraqi Civil Code.

Conditions for Application

This theory applies if, during the validity of the contract, general exceptional events occur that:

Could not have been foreseen at the time of conclusion.
Result in the execution of the contractual obligation becoming extremely burdensome to the debtor.
Threaten the debtor with exorbitant loss, even if execution has not reached the level of impossibility.

Judicial Authority

In such cases, the court may, upon the debtor's request and after balancing the interests of both parties:

Reduce the burdensome obligation to a reasonable limit.
This is done if justice so requires.
This constitutes a judicial amendment of the contract.

Practical Examples and Legal Restrictions

Practical examples of these exceptional circumstances include:

A sharp rise in prices generally.
Specifically, a surge in the prices of construction materials.

Such events would make the Musatah's execution of the agreed specifications (for buildings or facilities) a matter that exposes them to grave loss that was not calculated at the time of contracting.

Legislative Stance:

Flexibility: The legislator left the door open for the will of the contracting parties to amend the contract terms by mutual agreement if such events occur.
Mandatory Law: It is worth noting that the legislator explicitly stated in Article 146 itself that it is not permissible to agree on matters contrary to its provisions.
Invalidity of Waiver: This means parties cannot agree in advance to exclude the application of the Theory of Unforeseen Circumstances. If the contract contains such a clause, it is considered void and is disregarded.

Consequently, either party has the right to resort to the judiciary if a dispute arises regarding the amendment of contract terms and they fail to reach a consensual agreement that relieves the burden on the aggrieved party to a reasonable limit.

Consensual Amendment of Terms

Regarding consensual amendment, this may be effected by agreement of the parties, whether at the initial conclusion of the contract or at a later stage during its validity.

Amendment of Remuneration (Rent)

One of the most prominent issues where the legislator allowed freedom of amendment is the issue of rent/remuneration. The parties may agree to:

Fix a specific rent: To be paid periodically and continuously.
Free Musataha: Make the right free of charge entirely.
Adjustment: Reduce the rent in proportion to price changes in the country.
Exemption: Exclude the Musatah from paying rent completely.
Lump Sum: Pay the rent in a single installment covering the entire duration.

Specific Settlement Clause: The parties may even agree that if the Musatah delays payment for three years or more, the land owner has the right to utilize their land for a specific period to satisfy their right, instead of resorting to a request for contract rescission (termination).

Amendment of Duration (Time Limits)

Regarding the amendment of the Musataha duration, this is subject to a mandatory restriction set by the legislator:

Maximum Limit: It is not permissible to agree on a duration exceeding fifty (50) years.
Reduction of Term: If the parties agree on a longer duration, it shall be reduced to the legal maximum, and the excess is disregarded.

Prohibition on Extension via Hardship

It is not permissible to extend this duration beyond the mentioned ceiling, even if the conditions of the Theory of Unforeseen Circumstances are met.

Judicial Precedent: This was confirmed by the Federal Court of Cassation in its Decision No. 2388 on 15/10/2008, which ruled that:

If the duration is fixed by the Musataha contract, it cannot be extended upon the occurrence of unforeseen circumstances.
Instead, the remedy is to reduce the burdensome obligation if necessary to achieve a balance between the interests of the parties.

Renewal of the Contract

However, the parties may agree to renew the Musataha right after its expiration for a new term, provided that:

This new term also does not exceed fifty years.
This renewal is registered at the Real Estate Registration Department to produce its legal effects as a registered Musataha right.

Here is the professional translation of the legal text regarding the expiration of the Musataha contract, formatted for clarity, SEO, and legal accuracy.

Expiration of the Musataha Contract

The Musataha contract, and the rights resulting from it for the Musatah (Surface Right Holder), is by nature a temporary contract in which time constitutes a fundamental element.

It is a fixed-term contract that extinguishes upon the expiration of its duration. As previously stated, this duration must not exceed fifty years as a maximum limit.

If the parties agree on a shorter duration, the agreement is valid, and the contract ends upon the expiration of the agreed term.
If the agreement lacks a specified duration for the Musataha right, the legislator has addressed this case in Article 1267/Para 1 of the Iraqi Civil Code No. 40 of 1951.

Legal Provision for Undefined Terms:

(The duration of the Musataha right may not exceed fifty years. If the duration is not determined, either the Musatah or the land owner may terminate the contract three years after giving notice to the other party).

Thus, the law permits either party to terminate the contract after three years from the time of notifying the other party. Consequently, the Musataha right extinguishes due to several causes, detailed as follows:

First: Expiration of the Term

The Musataha right extinguishes upon the end of the duration specified in the contract. As mentioned, this cannot exceed fifty years.

Automatic Expiration: If the contract reaches its specified term, the Musataha right extinguishes by operation of law without the need for an eviction notice, unless such a notice was stipulated in the contract.
Undefined Duration: If the term was not defined by agreement, either party may terminate the contract, provided they give notice to the other party three years prior to the desired termination date.

Survival of Rights:

The Musataha right does not cease merely because the building disappears before the end of the prescribed term. The right remains valid and productive of its effects regardless of the physical existence of the facilities, as long as the term has not yet expired.
Furthermore, this right does not extinguish upon the death of the Musatah; rather, it transfers via inheritance to their heirs, each according to their share of the estate, pursuant to Article 1269/Para 2 of the Iraqi Civil Code.

Second: Rescission of the Contract (Termination for Breach)

The Musataha right also extinguishes if the contract is rescinded (terminated) according to legal provisions.

Non-Payment of Rent (Article 1268): According to Article 1268 of the Civil Code:

If rent is agreed upon for the Musataha right, and the Musatah delays payment for three consecutive years, the land owner may request the rescission of the contract from the competent court.
This applies unless there is an agreement between the parties to the contrary.

Methods of Rescission:

Mutual Agreement: According to Article 234 of Real Estate Registration Law No. 43 of 1971, the parties may agree to terminate the contractual relationship by mutual consent before the term expires.
Judicial Rescission: By a final and conclusive judicial judgment, pursuant to Article 177 of the Iraqi Civil Code No. 40 of 1951.

Judicial Precedent: The Federal Court of Cassation, in Decision No. 2457/Real Estate Appellate Body/2021, ruled that: (If one of the parties to the Musataha contract breaches their obligations, the other party has the right to request rescission of the contract with compensation).

Third: Merger of Rights (Consolidation)

The Musataha right extinguishes in the event of a Merger of Rights (Union of Qualities), where the ownership of the land and the ownership of the Musataha right (and its buildings) are united in one person.

Legal Basis: This is stipulated in Article 234/Para 1/A of the Real Estate Registration Law No. 43 of 1971.
Mechanism: This merger occurs through the transfer of the Musataha right to the land owner, or the transfer of the land ownership to the Musatah, by any cause of acquiring ownership.
Result: All authorities granted by the right of ownership gather in one person, and the Musataha right extinguishes accordingly.

Examples of Merger:

The land owner becomes the heir to the Musataha right (if there are no other heirs).
The land ownership transfers to the Musatah via inheritance.
The Musatah sells their right directly to the land owner.

In all these cases, the separated elements of ownership are joined in the hands of one person, ending the Musataha right through this consolidation.

Fourth: Expropriation (Eminent Domain)

The Musataha right extinguishes if the competent authority decides to expropriate the real estate upon which this right is established.

Compensation Calculation:

The Musataha holder is entitled to a portion of the expropriation compensation equivalent to the value of utilizing the right for the remaining years of its term.
This is calculated after deducting the annual rent agreed upon between them and the land owner, as well as maintenance expenses, wages, and fees applicable during that period.

Scenario A: No Construction Yet If the Musatah has not yet erected the agreed-upon buildings on the expropriated property at the time of the expropriation request:

Their share of the compensation is limited to no more than 10% of the compensation.
Plus whatever annual rent they effectively paid to the land owner for the years preceding the expropriation request.

Scenario B: Construction Completed In cases where the Musatah has completed the construction of buildings or facilities:

They own these structures based on the Musataha right.
The expropriating authority is obligated to pay fair compensation for both the land and the building, regardless of the separate rights of the owner and the Musatah.
The distribution of the expropriation compensation between the parties is then determined according to the terms of the Musataha contract and their agreement, pursuant to Article 35 of the Expropriation Law No. 12 of 1981.

Important Note on Transfer of Ownership: It should be noted that the expiration of the defined term of the Musataha right does not result in the automatic transfer of ownership of the buildings and facilities to the land owner.

This transfer requires registration at the Real Estate Registration Department.
This is done either by the consent of both parties or by force of law (court order).
Only then is the contract considered extinguished, and the facilities revert to the land owner in accordance with the provisions of Article 1270 of the Iraqi Civil Code.

For expert legal advice on property rights and contracts, contact Osama Tuma for Legal Services and Advisory. Trust a leading law firm in Iraq to protect your interests and guide you through complex legal matters.